top of page

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power: Seasons 1 & 2: A Very Slow Start Eventually Yields Better Results (4K)

Jeff Beck
16 minutes ago
6 min read

The Show:


As soon as it was announced that a television show based on material from "The Lord of the Rings" was being developed for Amazon Prime Video, it immediately grabbed the attention of every Tolkien fan around the world, as well as fans of Sir Peter Jackson's Middle-earth films in general. It brought with it great anticipation of how incredible such a show could be if done properly, with the same care that had been given to the films (even though it would not involve Jackson), but it also brought a fair amount of concern in regards to being able to do justice to such a vast world of material on a smaller screen.


However, with a number of epic programs that could be cited as successful examples of shows on such a scale ("Game of Thrones," "Rome," etc.), there seemed reason to be optimistic that it could potentially turn out to be something truly special. With the first two seasons receiving separate stunning 4K releases this month to coincide with the premiere of the latest season, it's time to have a look at the show's progress thus far to see how well showrunners J. D. Payne and Patrick McKay have done in bringing this material to television. Is it everything that LOTR fans could've hoped for, or are they in for an epic disappointment?


As the show involves multiple storylines, I'll attempt to be brief in regards to each one. We start with the backstory involving the war between the Elves and the dark lord Morgoth, who is eventually defeated and replaced by Sauron. Finrod, brother of Galadriel (Morfydd Clark), is killed while hunting Sauron, leading his sister to take over. With little progress in the hunt, her men decide to give up, forcing her to return to Lindon, the Elven capital. The High King Gil-galad (Benjamin Walker) gives her the honor of returning to Valinor, an honor that her friend Elrond (Robert Aramayo) gets her to accept, though as we soon see, she's not quite ready to give up, which puts her on a much different path. Meanwhile, Elrond meets the celebrated Elven smith Celebrimbor (Charles Edwards), who needs help with an upcoming project he's working on, putting Elrond on a path to reunite with his old dwarf friend, Prince Durin (Owain Arthur)


When the news that war with Sauron is over reaches a group of Elves watching over a village of Morgoth's descendants, an Elf named Arondir (Ismael Cruz Córdova) is reluctant to leave because he has become close to a human healer called Bronwyn (Nazanin Boniadi). When a villager with a sick cow arrives from a nearby village, the two go to investigate, while Theo (Tyroe Muhafidin), Bronwyn's son, finds an old broken sword with Sauron's mark on it, which will play a role in events to come. Finally, we also follow a group of Harfoots, led by Sadoc Burrows (Lenny Henry), who travel from place to place while trying to avoid being seen by humans and other big folk. Young Nori Brandyfoot (Markella Kavenagh) has always been rather curious, but when she and her friend Poppy (Megan Richards) come across a stranger (Daniel Weyman) in a crater, she just might get more than she bargained for.


"The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power" has had a strange and somewhat difficult transition to the small screen in these first two seasons, one that's brought with it some unfortunate lows, but also some optimistic peaks that show a fair amount of promise. The problems primarily reside in the show's first season, where the single biggest issue it faces is the fact that it takes a very, very long time to get its multiple storylines moving. There are several episodes (each an hour longer or more) that do quite a lot of setting things up, introducing characters, plots, and basically doing a ton of world building, but with very few advancements in the various stories. Sure, the characters do a lot of traveling as they get themselves into position, so we get to see a good deal of Middle-earth along the way, but the frustration slowly builds up as you patiently wait for it to truly dive into the material and tell a compelling tale.


That said, it does finally start to take shape near the end as the season's major threat, a group of orcs led by Adar (Joseph Mawle), attempts to make a home for themselves, but by then it's a little too late to save the show's debut outing after having to wait so incredibly long for it to finally start giving us more engaging material. To that end, it's understandable as to why so many became disillusioned with the show rather quickly, with the numbers saying that only 37% of viewers actually finished the first season, and the total minutes watched dropping 60% from season one to season two. It's understandable, but it's also just a bit of a shame, because as we soon see, the showrunner's apparently learned a thing or two from the mistakes they made in its initial outing.


For season two, it's great to be able to say that there isn't much waiting in regards to advancements in the storylines. In fact, one can easily say that this is where they finally start to delve into much more engaging aspects of it, exploring areas such as the forging of additional rings (which involves some deception from a well-known villain), a certain wizard trying to discover himself, family drama with the Dwarves under the mountain, and the building up of a climactic battle that takes place at season's end. It still might not be as riveting as viewers were hoping, but as far as keeping their attention with more compelling storylines, it certainly does a far better job than the overly-sluggish first season.


Of course, one cannot do the show any kind of justice without mentioning its absolutely stunning visual/technical elements. From the gorgeous production design, costumes, and makeup to the incredible cinematography, visual effects, and direction, it is simply jaw-dropping to look at. While the writing may waver here and there, there's no denying that the show is quite the visual feast, an element that, even if one remembers nothing else about it, makes it stand out. With the exorbitant amount of money spent per episode, it's good to see that it's being put to good use in helping to bring this world to life.


All things considered, "The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power" did indeed have a very rough start. Obviously Payne & McKay should've rethought their approach to the material, getting to the point a lot faster than they did. There's nothing wrong with doing a little setting-up & world-building, but you simply can't leave your audience waiting around for hours before your show finally starts. This is why it's good to see that they figured that out for the sophomore outing, which keeps its pace & developments steady throughout. It may have mixed results thus far, but at least there's reason to be optimistic about the third season. The wheels of the show are turning, now these two just need to keep it up.


Video/Audio:


"The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power: Seasons 1 & 2" come to 4K in 2.39:1, 2160p Ultra High Definition transfers of marvelous quality. Each of the 16 episodes presents a gorgeously sharp picture throughout, perfectly highlighting the show's beautiful designs & impressive technical elements. Likewise, the Dolby Atmos-TrueHD audio tracks are outstanding, giving you all of the dialogue, sound effects, and music in excellent quality. Overall, MGM has done a phenomenal job in both areas for each season's physical debut.


Special Features:


Season 1:


The Making of The Rings of Power (8 Featurettes): Brief looks behind the scenes of each episode.


Building Middle-earth (5 Featurettes, 22 Minutes): A series of featurettes that delve into different areas of the show, including the music, the costumes, and the production design.


Cast Bootcamp (5 Minutes): A look at the training the cast went through.


Sundering Seas (5 Minutes): A featurette that explores the show's water scenes.


Stores of the Second Age (5 Featurettes, 6 Minutes): Very brief looks at the various groups of Middle-earth.


Season 2:


Season 1 Recap (3 Minutes)


Inside Episodes (8 Featurettes): A series of featurettes that go behind the scenes of each episode.


The Battle of Eregion (10 Minutes): A featurette that delves into the season's climactic battle.


Conclusion:


"The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power: Seasons 1 & 2" present rather mixed results for the highly-anticipated small-screen adaptation of Tolkien's appendices material thus far. The debut outing quickly loses its way by getting bogged down with its set-ups, character introductions, and world-building, and while it does start to improve by the end of the season, it isn't until season two where the show finally finds its footing, delving into far more interesting areas of the material and making sure that the pacing & developments remain steady. It may take quite a while to get where it's going, but at least it looks absolutely stunning the whole way, and with its storylines finally chugging along, viewers now have reason to be optimistic about its third installment.


Season One: 3/5


Season Two: 3.5/5


Now available on 4K.


Follow me on Twitter @BeckFilmCritic.




Comments


Join our mailing list

bottom of page