top of page

The Dirty Dozen: The Definitive 'Men on a Mission' Classic Makes Its 4K Debut (Limited Edition 4K)

Jeff Beck
2 minutes ago
5 min read

The Film:


"Men on a Mission" films have long been a popular staple of cinema, encompassing such classics as "The Guns of Navarone," "Force 10 from Navarone, and "Where Eagles Dare," but it's more than fair to say that when the genre is brought up, the very first one that springs to mind as the most classic example is Robert Aldrich's "The Dirty Dozen." Indeed, Lee Marvin leading a group of rag-tag prisoners behind enemy lines to kill some Nazis stands tall as not only a critical, but major box office success, one that even managed to garner four Oscar nominations (including a win for Best Sound Effects), with its influence and popularity continuing quite strongly over the decades.


With the film's 60th anniversary right around the corner, Arrow Films has decided to celebrate by giving the war classic a stunning 4K upgrade and packing it full of special features (which includes not only new and archival material, but also the film's TV sequel), so now it's time to revisit this popular entry in the genre to see how well it's held up over the last six decades. Does it still pack the same punch it did all those years ago, or has it perhaps wilted just a little with age?


"The Dirty Dozen" starts in March 1944, with Major John Reisman (Lee Marvin) receiving orders from Major General Sam Worden (Ernest Borgnine) to head "Project Amnesty," a top secret mission that will have him training a dozen Army prisoners to go behind enemy lines and kill as many Nazi officers as possible at a chateau near Rennes in order to disrupt their chain of command right before D-Day. The 12 prisoners are all facing sentences of death or hard labor, but should they complete the mission, a possible amnesty awaits them. These guys are certainly a rough batch, having committed crimes such as murder, assault, and theft, but eventually they come to form a pretty good team. However, will it be enough to carry out a mission that many see as a one-way ticket?


Indeed, "The Dirty Dozen" (adapted by Nunnally Johnson and Lukas Heller from the novel by E.M. Nathanson) is considered to be the definitive example of the "men on a mission" genre, utilizing its lengthy 150-minute runtime to take us through the process from beginning to end, from receiving the orders to training the men to executing the dangerous mission. That said, it's not a film without some flaws, which hold it back just a little in terms of its greatness. As mentioned, this is a two and a half hour film that follows the entire ordeal, though it's more than fair to say that it gets a little bogged down when it comes to the training of these convicts, which takes up quite a significant portion of its runtime.


Of course, it's important to show us how they prepare and how they start to rely on each other & function as a unit, but this segment of the film is simply stretched out a little too much, even more so when you tack on the exercise that follows (given to them so that they can prove that they're ready). When we finally come to the actual mission, it's a little disappointing to find that it's only about the last third or so of the film, but my goodness, it's a final third that's certainly worth waiting for. Here we get to watch the boys put all of their training to use to pull off this insane stunt, which obviously wouldn't be complete without a few hiccups along the way. It's exciting, tense, unpredictable, and keeps you glued to the screen in anticipation of seeing who, if anyone, is going to make it out of this mess alive.


Naturally, the film's marvelous ensemble has to be mentioned as well, without whom it wouldn't work half as well as it does. Assembled here are big names like Oscar winner Lee Marvin, Oscar winner Ernest Borgnine, Oscar winner George Kennedy, Donald Sutherland, Telly Savalas, Charles Bronson, Robert Ryan, Ralph Meeker, and John Cassavetes, whose performance earned him an Oscar nod (which he ironically lost to co-star George Kennedy for "Cool Hand Luke"). It's a hell of a cast indeed, and easily one of the film's most memorable & impressive elements, especially given how they're able to take what could've been a rather bland, simple story and turn it into something quite thrilling.


Overall, while its excess in the earlier portions of the film may bring it down a little in stature, "The Dirty Dozen" still packs quite a punch, leaving a major impact with its compelling tale & stellar ensemble. There's certainly a reason why it's endured as a war classic for nearly 60 years, and now that it's getting a stunning UHD upgrade, it can continue to be revered in the best quality possible. Whether you're a long-time fan, or are somehow just discovering it now, it's definitely a worthy addition to any collection.


Video/Audio:


"The Dirty Dozen" comes to 4K in a 1.85:1, 2160p Ultra High Definition transfer of spectacular quality. The new restoration from the original 35mm camera negative looks absolutely incredible, giving you a beautifully sharp image throughout the entire 150-minute presentation. Likewise, the restored lossless mono, 5.1 audio, and the newly restored 6.0 (70mm mix) soundtracks are fantastic, giving you all of the dialogue, Oscar-winning sound effects, and Frank De Vol's score in excellent quality. Overall, Arrow Films has done a phenomenal job in both departments for this classic war film's new upgrade.


Special Features:


Commentary with Actors Jim Brown, Trini Lopez, Stuart Cooper, and Colin Maitland, Producer Kenneth Hyman, Novelist E.M. Nathanson, Film Historian David J. Schow, and Veteran Military Advisor Capt. Dale Dye


Archival Introduction to the Film by Actor Ernest Borgnine (4 Minutes)


The Dirty Dozen: Next Mission (96 Minutes): A feature-length TV sequel starring Lee Marvin and Ernest Borgnine (standard definition only).


Newly Discovered on Set Footage (14 Minutes) and an Interview with Lee Marvin (6 Minutes) from Peter Whitehead's Archive


War is Over (24 Minutes) (New): An appreciation by film historian Kim Newman.


The War March (38 Minutes) (New): A breakdown of Frank De Vol's score by David Huckvale.


Armed and Deadly: The Making of The Dirty Dozen (31 Minutes): An archival featurette from 2006 on the making of the film.


The Filthy Thirteen: Real Stories Behind the Lines (47 Minutes): An archival featurette on the history behind the film.


Operation Dirty Dozen (9 Minutes): An original promotional featurette from 1967.


Combat Leadership: The Ultimate Challenge (30 Minutes): A Marine Corps recruitment film from 1986 narrated by Lee Marvin.


Conclusion:


Robert Aldrich's "The Dirty Dozen" may get a little bogged down in certain portions of its classic "men on a mission" tale, but it more than makes up for it with its spectacular & thrilling final act, as well as a marvelous ensemble of big names, ultimately making for a war classic that hold up quite well, even after 60 years.


Score: 3.5/5


Available on Limited Edition 4K starting today.


Follow me on Twitter @BeckFilmCritic.



Comments


Join our mailing list

bottom of page